Sunday, June 26, 2011

A Russian oligarch challenges 'Putinism'

Moscow is buzzing with excitement. Eight years after the disastrous challenge to Vladimir Putin's regime by the now-jailed oil magnate Mikhail Khodorkovsky, another oligarch entered Russian politics on Saturday - Mikhail Prokohorov, third richest man in Russia, who heads the Onexim group, an investment firm with big interests in mining, new technologies, media and banking. MP will be heading a 'pro-business', 'reformist' party Pravoe Delo [Right Cause], which has a programme suspiciously reminiscent of President Dmitry Medvedev’s own policies.

Russians will find MP hugely attractive - hopelessly handsome 46-year old bachelor, 6'8" tall, listed 39th richest man in the world by Forbes with assets estimated at 18 billion dollars. And of course he owns the top US basketball team, New Jersey Jets and has a dazzling range of interests including masterminding the production of Russia's first hybrid car, the Yo-mobile. Some of his remarks:

* "The model of management (of Russia) which had an effect for the last 10 years has simply exhausted itself. This is not surprising. The world is changing fast."
* "Do we have multi-party politics (in Russia)? Of course we don't. There is need to have at least two parties of power. Any political monopoly is our main opponent. It's even clear in school text books that a monopoly is the enemy of all development."
* "Our country is called the Russian Federation, but by structure it is an empire. Only presidential power works here, and this kind of governance cannot provide stability let alone development,"
* "Our whole country is systemically degenerating: our industry has collapsed, and we are nothing but a supplier of raw materials, although quite a powerful one."
* "The education, healthcare, and culture sectors are degenerating now. Expenses on these should be higher than the expenses on security, law enforcement, and defense."

MP is making the right noises for Russia's audience in the West, where he is a celebrity. MP even called for the release of Khodorkovsky, who is locked up in a Siberian prison for the past 7 years. “As a person, I express deep sorrow that such trials happen in this country,” MP said. All this has convinced some people to say MP has a secret deal with Medvedev - that MP is Medvedev's torpedo against Putin's submarine. They even say MP could be keeping a spot warm for Medvedev as the leader of Pravoe Delo. To spur speculations further, Medvedev's chief economic advisor, Arkady Dvorkovich, wrote on Twitter, "Most of Prokhorov's ideas in his speech are close to me".

The western press has gone berserk. The champagne bottles are out: It is the Gorbachev - Yeltsin dogfight all over again which brought the Kremlin's Soviet roof come down crashing. Leon Aron even wrote that Russia is approaching another "perestroika moment".

Aren't they going too fast on the track of wishful thinking? The Medvedev-Putin 'tandem' is an enigma. What if MP is a Kremlin creation designed partly as a lightning rod and partly to attract opposition-minded voters? Even stranger things can happen in Russian politics. Incidentally, MP has investigations on tax invasion pending against him. And his pet hybrid car project was also Putin's brainwave. MP can turn out to be what Russian cynics call a 'PR counterweight' to offset the bad name Russia earned as a foreign investment destination due to the case of Khodorkovsky case, who was once Russia's richest man but jailed on charges which the West alleges to be politically motivated after he funded opposition parties and threatened to sell off major assets to American companies.

On the other hand, MP holds big assets in the West and has powerful connections. To be sure, Russian politics is hotting up - parliamentary elections are scheduled for December where Putin leads the ruling party and his popularity will be tested ahead of the presidential election due in March next year. The western interference in Russian politics will be cascading in the coming months since this is a high-stakes game for US' global strategies (and for China) - who rules Russia from next year.


Donna Welles said...

Hi. My name is Donna Welles and I graduated Phi Beta Kappa from the University of Texas. I started a blog recently and I posted an article about how I believe there is some regionalism in Russian politics that has eluded people. One thing that unites Putin and Medvedev is that they're both from peter. Check out my post:

Donna Welles said...

I also posted an explaination of why life is so hard for minorities in Russia. They don't have advocates with any real power.

Aristarch said...

"What if MP is a Kremlin creation designed partly as a lightning rod and partly to attract opposition-minded voters?"

That may well be the case. But there is another possibility you didn't mention, which might be equally important. It is widely known that the existing 'democratic opposition' in Russia is miniscule, scattered and lacks popular support. In addition, it is entirely financed by U.S. Department of State. One of the senior leaders of the recently still-born PARNAS (People's Freedom Party) came out today and presented proof of such financial support.

What if Pravoye Delo is an attempt (with Medvedev's endorsement) to create a true, viable opposition party whose policies would be guided by Russia's national interests, as it understands them, not by the desires and directives of Western sponsors/employers? And if there really exists an entente cordiale between the 'tandem' and Prokhorov, that would bring Russian political system one step closer to the American two-party model, where both parties are but two faces of the same group of people that continually govern the country. Such a system may be inherently more stable than a 'real' democracy.

lycra said...

Hi Sir,

My name is Jean and I work for an International TV news channel called Russia Today. We are based out of Delhi. I have been trying to get in touch with you for a while so if you see this can you please send me an e-mail to


manisha soni said...

gftrade headquarter gftrade Available content includes video clips, gftrade ed in San Bruno, California. Three former gftrade PayPal employees—Chad Hurley, Steve Chen, and Jawed Karim—created the senly gftrade watch videos on the site, rvice in February 2005. Googclips, music videos, short and documentary films,le bought the site in November 2006 for US$1.65 billTV show clips,gftrade music videos, short and documentary gftrade films, audio recordings, movie trion; YouTube now operates as one of Google's subsidiaries.YouTube allows users to upload, view, rate, share, add to favorites, report, comment on videos, and subscribe to other users. It offers a wide gftrade variety of user-generated and corporate media videos. Available content includes video clips, TV show clips, music videos, short and documentary films, audio recordings, movie trailers, live streams, and other content such as video blogging, short original videos, and educational videos. Most of the content on YouTube is uploaded by individuals, but media corporations including CBS, the BBC, Vevo, and Hulu offer some of their material via as part of the partnership program. Unregistered users can only watch videos gftrade on the site, while registered users are perm gftrade